Join WEbook

WEbook is the largest online writing community. Get writing advice, feedback and much more.

Start Now!

911 Writer's Block
Break the block!

Post & Share Your Writing
Writing challenges, feedback & much more.

PageToFame
Test out your work. Find out what readers think of your first page.

AgentInbox
Submit your work to a lit agent. Right here.

« Got Tough Skin? | Main | Can You Juggle? »

May 17, 2010

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00e54ff9f2cf8834013480eee0b7970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference A Good Ending Challenge Results + New Flash Fiction Challenge:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Aubrie

I'm sorry, but are the rules even taken into consideration when the winners are chosen? No offense to the writers who were recieves 1st and 2nd place, their piece were very nice, but over the word count. Granted AlexVolt was only over by 2, but vivalavida was over by 21, and not because WEbook messed up the count.

Personally, I feel RhindraVekrah was royally gipped, considering they followed ALL the rules and ended up in 3rd. Perhaps if given 21 more words they would have won. Maybe someone else would have won.

Again, nothing against the authors, but why post a word count rule if even the judges won't follow it? Call it a guidline or a suggestion, but please don't make it a rule and then completely disregard it in the end. What's the point then?

Kristal

I think there was alot better entries out there and I think the one that one was biased where is the new want for new writing. Why is it the same formula? The same boring old crap! No offence to the top three but, I was unimpressed! I can't believe that the people out there that put out a whole new set of thoughts didn't even make it into the top three. That is crap and what is up with the crap that if your in the UK you can't entry the page or the Agent thing!!!!!! This site's just not worth it.

Carrie

Yes I agree I was no impressed either. I liked the last story about Curiousity and the Death of a Cat but I read many others stories that were waaaay more interesting. Boo.

Maggie DiGiovanni

Enjoyed the entries. Keep the contests coming. Loved choice for first place. Second place nicely written. Third place could have been a bit stronger, but good concept.

Aubrie

That's what I am saying! If third place had disregarded the word count, like the others, their piece could have been stronger.

Going over the word count gave others an unfair advantage and it's sad that the rules are not governed more strictly to prevent this from happening.

Ashley

i say you all need to stop griping about it. seriously, it makes you look like sore losers. i'm certain, that if you had won over the word count, you wouldnt be pointing it out.

Enid

I am amazed at the number of poorly written comments on a site that has to do with writing, learning and improving one's talents? In this case, only the last three entries above mine have correct spelling, grammar, syntax, punctuation, etc. Congratulations to them!
For the others, please get tutoring or books on the topics where you need help. A publisher won't even glance at an article or book if it isn't perfectly correct.
EABCE

morleyt2009

Is it me or does the winning submission too closely resemble "The Lottery" by Shirley Jackson?

Aubrie

There is no way that I could win and be over the word count at the same time, because I follow the rules! Just calling those of us who are upset "sore losers" is a scapegoat! Our arguements are logical and our frustrations are justified!

A competition is not a competition without rules. The rules make the competition fair and are the basis of the challenge. The point of the competition was to write an ending in 100 words or less. If you did not do that, then you did not follow directions and did not challenge yourself!!!

And the most disappointing thing of all is that WEbook did not enforce their own rules, rewarding those who challenged themselves by staying within the bounds of the competition and creating something great at the same time.

It's not a difficult concept.

Brenda

My ending was 163 words. I cut it down to 100. Follow directions or don't participate. This is the first thing that came up on my page and did not realize all that this site involves.

MM

Don't you know that it is obvious that hardly any of these submissions to these competitions are read? And if they are, one wonders just who is readng them. There were many excellent entries that kicked these suckers way out of the ballpark. It is the same time after time after time, mediocrity and derivativess win out ... always. I personally think the first three that have no errors that are read become the winners. And to the person telling everyone to stop wining ... you shut up. These are very valid points and you are exactly what is wrong with the writing world for letting these atrocities happen. Let's see what 'winners' there will be for the flash fiction - hopefully the fact that they are taking two weeks to judge this time means someone will actually be reading them - for I don't care what they say, it is evident that they are not being read. Not only do these stories suck, but they are written simplistically with absolutely no identity to them whatsoever that would set them apart. But then that's what happens when the majority of people here are teenage girls.

Brian

Hey MM, I can assure you that the WEbook staff does read and consider every submission to each challenge. In fact, we are having a guest judge for The Character Creation Challenge who is an editorial assistant at St. Martin's Press.

Aubrie

It's fantastic that someone is taking the time to read every submission, I'd expect nothing less, but can they follow their own rules at the same time? I don't want to beat the word count subject to death, but like I said, what's the point if that ONE very simple rule is not followed? I guess we'll see on June 11th when the flash fiction winners are announced. Good luck to everyone who wrote a piece in 110 words or less :) You deserve to be considered for your efforts.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Follow WEbook

Follow Me on Pinterest